Field Hockey
- 1982 Collegiate (D1), Steward (D2)
- 1983 Collegiate (D1)
- 1984 None
- 1985 Collegiate (D1), Steward (D2)
- 1986 Collegiate (D1)
- 1987 None
- 1988 Collegiate (D1)
- 1989 Collegiate (D1)
- 1990 Collegiate (D1)
- 1991 Steward (D2)
- 1992 Steward (D2)
- 1993 Collegiate (D1), Steward (D2)
- 1994 Collegiate
- 1995 Collegiate
- 1996 None
- 1997 Collegiate
- 1998 Collegiate
- 1999 none
- 2000 St. Catherine’s (D1), Steward (D2)
- 2001 Collegiate (D1), Steward (D2)
- 2002 Collegiate (D1), Steward (D2)
- 2003 Collegiate (D1), Covenant (D2)
- 2004 Collegiate (D1), Covenant (D2)
- 2005 Collegiate
- 2006 Collegiate (D1), Steward (D2)
- 2007 Collegiate (D1), Steward (D2)
- 2008 Collegiate (D1), Fredericksburg Academy (D2)
- 2009 Collegiate (D1), Fredericksburg Academy (D2)
- 2010 St. Catherine’s (D1), Covenant (D2)
- 2011 Collegiate
- 2012 St. Catherine’s
- 2013 St. Catherine’s (D1), St. Anne’s-Belfield (D2)
- 2014 Trinity Episcopal
- 2015 Trinity Episcopal
- 2016 Trinity Episcopal
- 2017 Trinity Episcopal
Cross Country
- 1986 St. Catherine’s
- 1987 St. Catherine’s
- 1988 St. Catherine’s
- 1989 St. Catherine’s
- 1990 St. Catherine’s
- 1991 St. Catherine’s
- 1992 St. Catherine’s
- 1993 St. Catherine’s
- 1994 Collegiate
- 1995 St. Catherine’s
- 1996 St. Catherine’s
- 1997 St. Catherine’s
- 1998 St. Catherine’s
- 1999 Collegiate
- 2000 St. Catherine’s
- 2001 St. Catherine’s
- 2002 St. Catherine’s
- 2003 Norfolk Academy
- 2004 St. Catherine’s
- 2005 St. Catherine’s
- 2006 Collegiate
- 2007 St. Catherine’s
- 2008 St. Catherine’s
- 2009 St. Catherine’s
- 2010 St. Catherine’s
- 2011 St. Catherine’s
- 2012 Trinity Episcopal
- 2013 St. Catherine’s
- 2014 St. Catherine’s
- 2015 St. Anne’s-Belfield
- 2016 St. Anne’s-Belfield
Tennis
- 1987 Collegiate
- 1988 Collegiate
- 1989 Collegiate
- 1990 Collegiate
- 1991 N/A
- 1992 St. Catherine’s
- 1993 St. Catherine’s
- 1994 St. Catherine’s
- 1995 Collegiate
- 1996 Collegiate
- 1997 Collegiate
- 1998 Collegiate
- 1999 St. Catherine’s
- 2000 Collegiate
- 2001 Collegiate
- 2002 Collegiate
- 2003 Collegiate
- 2004 Collegiate
- 2005 Collegiate
- 2006 Canceled
- 2007 St. Catherine’s
- 2008 St. Catherine’s
- 2009 Collegiate
- 2010 Collegiate
- 2011 Collegiate
- 2012 Collegiate
- 2013 Collegiate
- 2014 Collegiate
- 2015 Collegiate
- 2016 St. Catherine’s
- 2017 Collegiate
Volleyball
- 1989 Collegiate
- 1990 St. Catherine’s
- 1991 N/A
- 1992 Collegiate
- 1993 Collegiate
- 1994 Collegiate
- 1995 N/A
- 1996 Collegiate
- 1997 Collegiate
- 1998 N/A
- 1999 Collegiate
- 2000 Collegiate
- 2001 Collegiate
- 2002 Virginia Episcopal
- 2003 Collegiate
- 2004 Covenant
- 2005 Collegiate
- 2006 Covenant
- 2007 Collegiate
- 2008 Covenant
- 2009 St. Anne’s-Belfield
- 2010 St. Catherine’s
- 2011 Trinity Episcopal
- 2012 St. Catherine’s
- 2013 St. Catherine’s
- 2014 St. Catherine’s
- 2015 St. Catherine’s
- 2016 St. Catherine’s
Basketball
- 1984-85 St. Catherine’s
- 1985-86 St. Catherine’s
- 1986-87 N/A
- 1987-88 St. Catherine’s
- 1988-89 N/A
- 1989-90 N/A
- 1990-91 N/A
- 1991-92 St. Catherine’s
- 1992-93 Saint Gertrude (D1), Steward (D2)
- 1993-94 St. Catherine’s
- 1994-95 St. Catherine’s
- 1995-96 Saint Gertrude
- 1996-97 Saint Gertrude
- 1997-98 Saint Gertrude
- 1998-99 Saint Gertrude
- 1999-00 N/A
- 2000-01 Saint Gertrude
- 2001-02 Saint Gertrude (D1), St. Anne’s-Belfield (D2)
- 2002-03 St. Anne’s-Belfield (D1), Blessed Sacrament-Huguenot (D2)
- 2003-04 St. Anne’s-Belfield
- 2004-05 St. Anne’s-Belfield
- 2005-06 St. Anne’s-Belfield (D1), Trinity Episcopal (D2)
- 2006-07 St. Anne’s-Belfield (D1), Covenant (D2)
- 2007-08 St. Anne’s-Belfield (D1), Covenant (D2)
- 2008-09 St. Anne’s-Belfield (D1), Covenant (D2)
- 2009-10 St. Anne’s-Belfield (D1), Covenant (D2)
- 2010-11 St. Anne’s-Belfield
- 2011-12 St. Catherine’s
- 2012-13 St. Catherine’s
- 2013-14 St. Anne’s-Belfield
- 2014-15 St. Anne’s-Belfield
- 2015-16 St. Anne’s-Belfield
- 2016-17 St. Anne’s-Belfield
Indoor Track
- 1986-87 St. Catherine’s
- 1987-88 St. Catherine’s
- 1988-89 St. Catherine’s
- 1989-90 N/A
- 1990-91 St. Catherine’s
- 1991-92 N/A
- 1992-93 Collegiate
- 1993-94 Collegiate
- 1994-95 Collegiate
- 1995-96 Collegiate
- 1996-97 N/A
- 1997-98 N/A
- 1998-99 St. Catherine’s
- 1999-00 St. Catherine’s
- 2000-01 St. Catherine’s
- 2001-02 St. Catherine’s
- 2002-03 Norfolk Academy
- 2003-04 St. Catherine’s
- 2004-05 St. Catherine’s
- 2005-06 St. Catherine’s
- 2006-07 St. Catherine’s
- 2007-08 Collegiate
- 2008-09 Collegiate
- 2009-10 Collegiate
- 2010-11 St. Catherine’s
- 2011-12 St. Catherine’s
- 2012-13 St. Catherine’s
- 2013-14 St. Catherine’s
- 2014-15 St. Catherine’s
- 2015-16 St. Catherine’s
- 2016-17 St. Catherine’s
Swimming and Diving
- 1997-98 Collegiate
- 1998-99 Collegiate
- 1999-00 Collegiate
- 2000-01 Collegiate
- 2001-02 Collegiate
- 2002-03 Collegiate
- 2003-04 Collegiate
- 2004-05 St. Catherine’s
- 2005-06 St. Catherine’s
- 2006-07 St. Catherine’s
- 2007-08 St. Catherine’s
- 2008-09 St. Catherine’s
- 2009-10 St. Catherine’s
- 2010-11 St. Catherine’s
- 2011-12 Collegiate
- 2012-13 Collegiate
- 2013-14 Collegiate
- 2014-15 Collegiate
- 2015-16 Collegiate
- 2016-17 St. Catherine’s
Lacrosse
- 1984 Norfolk Academy
- 1985 Norfolk Academy
- 1986 Norfolk Academy
- 1987 St. Catherine’s
- 1988 St. Anne’s-Belfield
- 1989 St. Anne’s-Belfield
- 1990 St. Anne’s-Belfield
- 1991 St. Anne’s-Belfield
- 1992 St. Anne’s-Belfield
- 1993 St. Anne’s-Belfield
- 1994 St. Catherine’s
- 1995 Collegiate
- 1996 St. Catherine’s
- 1997 Collegiate
- 1998 St. Anne’s-Belfield
- 1999 Collegiate
- 2000 St. Anne’s-Belfield
- 2001 St. Anne’s-Belfield (D1), Trinity Episcopal (D2)
- 2002 St. Anne’s-Belfield (D1), Trinity Episcopal (D2)
- 2003 St. Anne’s-Belfield (D1), Covenant (D2)
- 2004 St. Anne’s-Belfield (D1), Covenant (D2)
- 2005 Collegiate
- 2006 Collegiate (D1), Trinity Episcopal (D2)
- 2007 Collegiate (D1), Trinity Episcopal (D2)
- 2008 Collegiate (D1), Trinity Episcopal (D2)
- 2009 Collegiate (D1), Covenant (D2)
- 2010 Collegiate (D1), Steward (D2)
- 2011 Collegiate
- 2012 Collegiate
- 2013 Collegiate
- 2014 Collegiate
- 2015 St. Anne’s-Belfield
- 2016 St. Anne’s-Belfield
- 2017 Collegiate
Soccer
- 1996 Collegiate
- 1997 Collegiate
- 1998 Collegiate
- 1999 Collegiate
- 2000 Collegiate
- 2001 Collegiate
- 2002 Collegiate
- 2003 Collegiate
- 2004 Collegiate
- 2005 Collegiate
- 2006 Collegiate
- 2007 Collegiate
- 2008 Collegiate
- 2009 Collegiate
- 2010 Collegiate (D1), Steward (D2)
- 2011 Collegiate
- 2012 St. Catherine’s
- 2013 St. Catherine’s
- 2014 St. Catherine’s
- 2015 St. Catherine’s
- 2016 St. Catherine’s
- 2017 Collegiate
Softball
- 1985 St. Gertrude
- 1989 St. Catherine’s
- 1990 St. Catherine’s
- 1991 Collegiate
- 1992 N/A
- 1993 St. Catherine’s
- 1994 St. Catherine’s
- 1995 St. Catherine’s
- 1996 St. Catherine’s
- 1997 Saint Gertrude
- 1998 Saint Gertrude
- 1999 N/A
- 2000 Collegiate
- 2001 Saint Gertrude
- 2002 Blessed Sacrament-Huguenot
- 2003 Collegiate
- 2004 Blessed Sacrament-Huguenot
- 2005 Collegiate
- 2006 Collegiate
- 2007 Collegiate
- 2008 Collegiate
- 2009 St. Catherine’s
- 2010 St. Margaret’s
- 2011 St. Catherine’s
- 2012 St. Catherine’s
- 2013 St. Margaret’s
- 2014 Covenant
- 2015 St. Margaret’s
- 2016 St. Margaret’s
- 2017 St. Margaret’s
Track and Field
- 1984 St. Catherine’s
- 1985 N/A
- 1986 N/A
- 1987 St. Catherine’s
- 1988 St. Catherine’s
- 1989 St. Catherine’s
- 1990 N/A
- 1991 St. Catherine’s
- 1992 Collegiate
- 1993 Collegiate
- 1994 Collegiate
- 1995 Collegiate
- 1996 St. Catherine’s
- 1997 N/A
- 1998 St. Catherine’s
- 1999 St. Catherine’s
- 2000 N/A
- 2001 Norfolk Academy
- 2002 St. Catherine’s
- 2003 St. Catherine’s
- 2004 St. Catherine’s
- 2005 St. Catherine’s
- 2006 St. Catherine’s
- 2007 St. Catherine’s
- 2008 Collegiate
- 2009 Norfolk Academy
- 2010 Collegiate
- 2011 St. Catherine’s
- 2012 St. Catherine’s
- 2013 Norfolk Academy
- 2014 St. Catherine’s
- 2015 Norfolk Academy
- 2016 Norfolk Academy
- 2017 St. Catherine’s
Spring Tennis
- 2001 Covenant
- 2002 Virginia Episcopal
- 2003 Virginia Episcopal
- 2004 Virginia Episcopal
Winter Soccer
- 1993-94 St. Catherine’s
- 1994-95 St. Catherine’s
- 1995-96 St. Catherine’s
- 1996-97 St. Catherine’s
- 1997-98 N/A
- 1998-99 St. Catherine’s
- 1999-00 N/A
- 2000-01 N/A
- 2001-02 St. Anne’s-Belfield
- 2002-03 St. Anne’s-Belfield
- 2003-04 Steward